The Case of Cooperative Mixed Duopoly
ثبت نشده
چکیده
The paper focuses on markets in which firms with different ownership structures compete with each other in a one-period Nash-Cournot setting. In particular the market outcome of a duopoly of one marketing cooperative and one private wholesaler (cooperative mixed duopoly) is compared to the outcomes of a public firm mixed duopoly and a pure private duopoly. None of these market arrangements are found to produce the first-best efficient outcome. However, both mixed markets improve efficiency compared to the private solution, and the overall welfare effects of the public firm mixed duopoly are superior to the cooperative mixed market. Finally, the distribution of surplus between the different producer groups and the different wholesaler firms is discussed. This paper was written while I was a Visiting Scholar at the Universi ty of Berkeley. I am grateful to Professor Trond Petersen for invit ing me, to the Institute of Industrial Relations for providing excellent office facilities and to The Norwegian National Research Council NAVF for necessary funding. I would also like to thank Professor Keeler and the students of the class "Industrial Organization and Public Regulation" for comments. Erling Barth, Steinar Vagstad and Jan-Erik Askildsen have contributed with valuable comments on an earlier draft. Remaining errors and short-comings are however mine.
منابع مشابه
The welfare effects of nationalization in a mixed duopoly public transport market
Recently, many cities have launched new rail transit lines. Once these new rail transit lines start commercial operation, they will play important roles as competitors to conventional bus services. In this paper, the effects of nationalization on equilibria have been studied in a mixed duopoly public transport market, in which one publicly-owned rail transit operator competes with one private b...
متن کاملA game theory approach to the sawnwood and pulpwood markets in the north of Iran
Duopoly game theory is applied to the wood industrial markets (sawnwood and pulpwood markets) in the North of Iran. The Nash equilibrium and the dynamic properties of the system based on marginal adjustments are determined. The probability that the Nash equilibrium will be reached is almost zero. The dynamical properties of sawnwood and pulpwood prices derived via the duopoly game model are fou...
متن کاملHotelling¡ ̄s Location Model in Mixed Duopoly
We investigate a mixed duopoly market where a welfare−maximizing public firm competes against a profit−maximizing private firm, using a linear−city location−then−price model with linear transportation costs. We find that, compared with the results in the purely private duopoly case discussed by Hotelling (1929) and d' Aspremont, Gabszewicz, and Thisse (1979), the condition under which price equ...
متن کاملIrrelevance of Conjectural Variation in a Mixed Duopoly: The Case of Relative Performance and Consistent Conjectures
This study explores the equilibrium outcomes in the contexts of quantity-setting and price-setting mixed duopolies with consistent conjectures of both the social welfare maximizing public firm and the relative profit maximizing private firm. Similar to the private duopoly composed of only relative profit maximizing firms, we show that in the mixed duopoly, the equilibrium outcomes in the quanti...
متن کاملCentralized Supply Chain Network Ddesign: Monopoly, Duopoly, and Ooligopoly Competitions under Uncertainty
This paper presents a competitive supply chain network design problem in which one, two, or three supply chains are planning to enter the price-dependent markets simultaneously in uncertain environments and decide to set the prices and shape their networks. The chains produce competitive products either identical or highly substitutable. Fuzzy multi-level mixed integer programming is used to mo...
متن کامل